It’s been about seven months since this kiln run, and I recently stripped and shredded the kilned leaves and the control leaves for the Burley to give them a taste side-by-side. I’ve now lit a few bowls of each, in random order, all in the same pipe. My experience surprised me.
Burley Leaf:
- Not kilned: It’s Burley. In a really good way. I’m not good at assigning food flavors to tobacco. The aroma is very pleasant and, well, like Burley. Is this what people call “nutty”? There is some harshness and a certain astringency mixed in. A little acetone on the retrohale. But overall, it’s not bad at all. I could see myself using this in a blend.
- Kilned: No more Burley aroma. It’s just spicy. Not the same kind of harshness or astringency as the unkilned version; that’s gone. But it’s pure hot sauce, without much flavor or aroma. Definitely not “nutty”. Burns my nose and tongue. What am I going to do with all this stuff?
Burley Red Tips:
- Not kilned: Strong. Harsh. The raw power makes it hard to pick out anything in terms of flavor or aroma. Rusty paint chips maybe?
- Kilned: Robust, round, strong, but smooth. Cigar-like. Malty. This is great. It made me think of German Schwarzbrot (though it obviously doesn’t really taste like it). If it weren’t so unreasonably high in nicotine, I would happily smoke this straight.
Admittedly, I must have gone into the tasting with a certain expectation. Going through all the effort and time to kiln this leaf must mean that there are significant improvements across the board, and the taste test was going to prove that to me. For the Red Tips, that’s absolutely true. I’m very happy how they turned out. For the Leaf, I’m disappointed. Yes, the harshness and off-flavors are gone, but so is all the pleasant Burley-ness. What’s left is just a spice bomb.
I also didn’t expect there to be such a marked difference between Leaf and Red Tips. They are just different stalk positions from the same harvest. I thought one would just end up a stronger version of the other.